Before I set off for New York, I trawled through every Best Dessert list I could find in every magazine and blog. Consistently, OTTO’s olive oil gelato was mentioned. The unique flavour has been on the menu at Mario Batali’s beloved Washington Square Italian restaurant since it opened nearly fifteen years ago, varying only with seasonal accompaniments. On our visit, it was paired with passionfruit granita, pomegranate sauce and pine nut brittle. We came back not long after for another one.
The revelatory flavour has also inspired a legion of sweet purveyors, including Marta’s olive oil affogato with honeycomb and cumquat, Narcissa’s winter sundae with olive oil ice cream and Meyer lemon curd, and Big Gay Ice Cream’s olive oil soft serve.
My rendition is adapted from the restaurant’s original recipe, but with more olive oil to play off the mandarin syrup I’ve swirled in. Make sure to use the best EVOO you can. For a plated dessert, segments of fresh mandarin and candied hazelnuts would go nicely.